This year’s midterm elections may ultimately be remembered for more than the sweeping changes they brought to government. The Nov. 3 election may mark the beginning of a significant realignment in American politics, particularly in the relationship between Christianity and the public square.
Among the most remarkable results were the victories of James Talarico in Texas and the Rev. Adam Hamilton in Kansas. Both are committed Christians who speak openly about how their faith informs their understanding of justice, compassion, human dignity and public responsibility. Their victories challenge a political assumption that has dominated American life for decades: that Christianity belongs naturally and almost exclusively to the political right.
For nearly half a century, since the formation of the Moral Majority in 1979, conservative evangelical Christianity and the Republican Party have maintained an increasingly powerful alliance. What began as an effort to give Christians a voice in public life gradually became a political identity, strengthened by Ronald Reagan’s election in 1980. Unfortunately, too often loyalty to political parties and their leaders has taken precedence over loyalty to the teachings of Jesus.
The problem is not that Christians participate in politics. Our faith calls us to engage the moral questions confronting society. The problem arises when the Gospel becomes subordinate to political power and Christianity becomes associated with exclusion rather than welcome, punishment rather than mercy and nationalism rather than compassion.
There is another Christian tradition, deeply rooted in Scripture, the Black Church, the Civil Rights Movement, and the social Gospel of Jesus Christ. It understands Christianity not simply as a promise of eternal salvation but as a responsibility to make God’s kingdom more visible in the world. I would describe this, as does Georgia Sen. Raphael Warnock, senior pastor of Atlanta’s historic Ebenezer Baptist Church, as “Matthew 25 Christianity.”
In Matthew 25:31–46, Jesus describes the final judgment in remarkably practical terms. Did you feed the hungry, give drink to the thirsty, welcome the stranger, clothe the naked, care for the sick and visit those in prison? Jesus concludes that whatever we do for the least among us, we do for him. He does not ask about political affiliation, party loyalty or religious credentials. He asks how we treat other human beings, particularly the most vulnerable.
Matthew 25 is not a partisan political platform, but neither can it be separated from public life. Hunger, poverty, affordable housing, health care, racial injustice, immigration and criminal justice are not simply matters of individual concern or charity. They are also questions of public policy that reflect the moral character of our society. This is where Matthew 25 Christians have an important role to play.
The victories of Talarico, Hamilton and others suggest that Americans may be increasingly receptive to candidates who approach politics through a moral vocabulary that transcends partisan loyalty. The challenge is not to create a Christian left to compete with a Christian right. It is to recover a Christianity that refuses to surrender its moral authority to either political party.
For those of us in the Episcopal tradition, this calling is reflected in our baptismal covenant: to seek and serve Christ in all persons, strive for justice and peace among all people and respect the dignity of every human being. These are not simply words spoken in worship. They are commitments that should shape how we live, vote, lead and participate in our communities.
The election results do not mean America’s political divisions have disappeared. But they may signal that the political monopoly some have claimed over Christianity is beginning to fracture. That offers hope to those of us who, in recent years, have listened to people claiming to be Christians and wondered, “What Gospels are they reading?”
Our nation does not need more politicians claiming that God is exclusively on their side. It needs more people willing to demonstrate that they are on the side of those Jesus called “the least of these.”
The midterm elections may have opened a new door. Whether that door leads to a healthier political culture, a more authentic Christian witness and a more compassionate nation remains to be seen. But the challenge for Christians is presently clear: We must move beyond defending Christianity as a political identity and begin living it as a moral responsibility. We must live as Matthew 25 Christians.
The Rev. Dr. Michael Shaffer
The Rev. Dr. Michael Shaffer is Rector of St. Mark’s Episcopal Church in downtown Charleston. He was a practicing attorney prior to entering ordained ministry. His is a husband, father and grandfather, as well as one of the founding members of the “Three Churches United,” a collaborative effort of the three historic African American Episcopal Churches on the peninsula.













